Oct 06, 2008 theory x and theory y was an idea devised by douglas mcgregor see article in his 1960 book the human side of enterprise. It implies that employees are reluctant to organizational changes. Theory x and y were created and developed by douglas mcgregor in the 1960s. Critically evaluate mcgregors theory x and theory y. A multilevel analysis of the effects of leaders managerial assumptions on follow ers attitudes december 2014 management decision 5210. Older, strictly hierarchical conceptions of c2, with narrow centralization of decision rights, highly constrained patterns of interaction, and limited information distribution tend to arise from cultural and organizational assumptions compatible with theory x. Theory x also assume that the employees have very little ambition but theory y assume the contrary that employees have a very high ambition.
How far is it applicable to management and employee motivation in contemporary chinese organizations. The workforce is changing nowadays, and the workplace is a dynamic mix of employees from different backgrounds, races and genders. Dec 25, 20 theory x and theory y relate to maslows hierarchy of needs in how human behavior and motivation are main priorities in the workplace in order to maximize output. Designmethodologyapproach an empirical study was conducted through. Pdf theory x and theory y type leadership behavior and.
Theory x and theory y team management training from. Pdf comparative analysis of theory x, theory y, theory z. Nov 01, 2008 a total of 279 superiors completed an online survey that measured theory x y orientation and superior communicator style. Despite these criticisms, mcgregors theory x and y have contributed to. If you believe that your team members dislike their work and have little motivation, then, according to mcgregor, youll likely use an authoritarian style of. While criticizing the contradictory assumptions of theory x and theory y lyndall f. The limitations of theory x and theory y motivation.
Critics of theory y, conversely, complain mostly about the freedom lovers. Because employees have historically been given a flat exchange of time and energy for income, workplace incentives have often been. In relation to theory y, the organization is trying to create the most symbiotic relationship between the managers and workers, which relates to maslows needs for selfactualization. Urwick was of this opinion thatthe primary task of every manager is to make or distribute goods or services at prices which the consumers are able and. Theory x says that the average human being is lazy and selfcentred, lacks ambition, dislikes change, and longs to. Empxtrack an integrated human capital and talent management tool is based on such theories and helps organizations to transform their human resource practices. Originalityvalue although mcgregors 1960 theory x and y have contributed to management and leadership thinking and practice for many years.
However, modern revisions including contingency theorists argue that theory y is not essentially a progressive alternative to a dull theory x. Jul 11, 2017 many years ago a professor named douglas mcgregor dubbed these perspectives theory x and theory y. Pdf purpose the purpose of this paper is to investigate the influence of leaders theory x and y managerial assumptions on subordinates. For simplicity, we write it as xy imagine concatenating the individual draws. Critically evaluate mcgregors theroy x and theory y. First, there has been a failure to distinguish between theory x y attitudes and theory x y behaviors. It encapsulated a fundamental distinction between management styles. Theory x and theory y were first explained by mcgregor in his book, the human side of enterprise, and they refer to two styles of management authoritarian theory x and participative theory y.
Because people dislike work they have to be coerced or controlled by management and. He referred to these opposing motivational methods as theory x and theory y management. Theory x and theory y allocate the job of management into two styles and, just like your algebra class, x and y dont work totally independently, although you can manage in a style that is mostly a theory x or theory y management style. Aug 05, 2019 in the case of theory x, the assumption is that workers or employee is do not tend to like work, but in the case of theory y there is the liking of work, and it is a natural process. Lets break each down and see how they apply in the workplace.
In his 1960 book, the human side of enterprise, douglas mcgregor proposed two theories by which to view employee motivation. Theory x and theory y are still referred to commonly in the field of management and motivation, and whilst more recent studies have questioned the rigidity of the model, mcgregors xy theory remains a valid basic principle from which to develop positive management style and techniques. Critically evaluate mcgregors theroy x and theory y bartleby. Before he died, mcgregor began to develop a further theory which addressed the criticisms made of theories. Theory x is a motivational theory, which involves high supervision and control over the subordinates, and greater degree of centralization. The three prior studies that have made this distinction were recently conducted solely to develop constructvalid measures of both. Douglas mcgregor, through his wellknown theory x and theory y, drew a. Theory x and theory y of motivation explain with examples. An exploratory study of the relationships between theory xy. In the modern corporation environment, employees motivation plays a pivotal role, thus they should be recognised as a significant part of corporations financial assets. Mar 08, 2008 theory x and theory y pertain to employee motivation and have been used in human resource management, organizational behavior analysis, and organizational development.
The major distinct disadvantage of theory x and theory y is that they are put forward as challenging sets of assumptions a supervisor is either motivated by theory x or by theory y. Theory x encourages use of tight control and supervision. It was in 1957 that douglas mcgregor first proposed the concept of theory x and theory y in the human side of. Motivation, theory x and y, classroom, management manager and organisation introduction douglas mcgregor, an american social psychologist, proposed his famous theory x and y in his book the human side of enterprise in 1960. Though these theories are very basic in nature, they provide a platform for future generations of management theorists and practitioners to understand the changing dynamics of human behavior.
Comparative analysis of theory x, theory y, theory z, and theory. Both of these theories begin with the premise that managements role is to. Critically evaluate mcgregors theroy x and theory y, sample. The limitations of theory x and theory y douglas mcgregor definition of theory x and theory y. The research paper on organisational objectives theory mcgregor managers. All about mcgregors theory x and theory y 12manage. Nov 10, 2020 developed in the 1960s by douglas mcgregor in his book, the human side of enterprise. Challenges and limitations of theory x and theory y motivation.
Theory y managers are likely to believe that employees are motivated by the value of their contribution. Organizational behaviour in the context of people management consists of several theories in which theory x, theory y, theory z are the newly introduced. Application of theory x and y in classroom management by. People view work as being as natural as play and rest. Douglas mcgregor, an american social psychologist, proposed his famous x y theory in his 1960 book the human side of enterprise. Introduction cont, is based upon maslows hierarchy of needs, in. In 1960, douglas mcgregor formulated theory x and theory y suggesting two aspects of human behaviour at work, or in other words, two different views of individuals employees. However, the literature has a limited number of studies concerning organizational performance of small and medium businesses, even less research on the impact on organizational performance of theory x and theory y type leadership styles. May 15, 2017 the major distinct disadvantage of theory x and theory y is that they are put forward as challenging sets of assumptions a supervisor is either motivated by theory x or by theory y. But the tyrannical behavior of this unprepossessing group arguably owes less to its theory of human nature x than to its beliefs about the noneliminable sources of human conflict t.
Challenges and limitations of theory x and theory y. Theory x percieves employees to be lazy, irresponsible and untrustworthy, while according to theory y employees are approached as one of the most valuable assets of the company. Mcgregors theory x and theory y organizational behavior. Theory x is perhaps visible in low paid or menial work but employees in those situations will move on in search of positions with theory y conditions if they are motivated. Difference between theory x and theory y with comparison. Theory x and theory y are theories of human work motivation and management. Theory x and theory y framework proposed by mcgregor in his classic book the human side of enterprise 1960 consists of two alternative set of assumptions.
Theory x and y is about managers beliefs about people and attitudes, which then translates into ways they choose to motivate their employees. Differentiate between theory x and theory y the idea that a managers attitude has an impact on employee motivation was originally proposed by douglas mcgregor, a management professor at the massachusetts institute of technology during the 1950s and 1960s. In contrast theory x, which stated that workers inherently dislike and avoid work and must be driven to it, and theory y, which stated that work is natural and can be a source of satisfaction when aimed at higher order human psychological needs, theory z focused on increasing employee loyalty to the company by providing a job for life with a. Theory x and theory y assumptions, merits and demerits. Theory x and theory y was an idea started by douglas mcgregor in the year 1960.
Therefore most people must be motivated by forcedbribed with the threat of punishment or a reward to produce effort and work towards organizational objectives. International journal of recent research aspects issn. According to theory y, when conditions are favorable, the individual finds work appealing and is highly motivated at need levels maslows hierarchy of needs. Both theories centre around the management styles in a working environment. Mcgregor proposed theory y assumptions about human nature as an alternative to theory x. Theory x and theory y 877 practical implications difficult to enact in environments characterized by several substantive questions might be researched continuous, turbulent exogenous changes, and by given the recent development of construct valid mea powerful external complexities requiring interorga sures of the focal variables in theory x and theory nizational, global, virtual teams. Pdf theory x and theory y type leadership behavior and its. Maslows hierarchy of needs theory has more critics than sup. Theory y managers favor a more collaborative approach, centering their leadership on trust, valuing creative problem solving, and managing by way of providing their employees with tools, opportunities, and visibility to do their jobs well. Nov 11, 2014 the purpose of this paper is to investigate the influence of leaders theory x and y managerial assumptions on subordinates attitudes and behaviors. Workers are committed and can work independently without direction to achieve.
Organizational behaviour in the context of people management consists of several theories in which theory x, theory y, theory z are the. Theory x and theory y work on assumptions i think organizations should be careful, and not rely too heavily on theory x and theory y because there are a lot of assumptions. It was first published in his book the human side of enterprise. Urwick proposed another theory of human behaviour at workplace which he has called theory z. They were created by douglas mcgregor while he was working at the mit sloan school of management in the 1950s, and developed further in the 1960s. Theory xy douglas mcgregor and theory z william ouichi theory x an authoritarian style of management the average worker dislikes work.
He avoided descriptive labels and simply called the theories theory x and theory y. Theory x and theory y organization, levels, style, manager, school. X and consider using the techniques suggested by theory y. Theory x and y was developed by douglas mcgregor, a social psychologist in 1960. Comparative analysis of theory x, theory y, theory z, and. Theory x people dislike work, have little ambition, and are unwilling to take responsibility. These differing management styles have been coined in the academic management community as theory x and theory y. Humans inherently dislike working and will try to avoid it if they can. Dec 04, 2020 the purpose of this paper is to apply mcgregors theory x and theory y to study teacher motivation in higher education.
Mcgregors theroy x and theory y in management free essay. Social exchange theory, theory x and y management styles, military personnel. Theory y maintains that human beings are active rather than passive shapers of. Apr 03, 20 leadership style and organizational performance have been researched extensively. Theory x and y management styles and effective commitment. Mcgregors most telling criticism of the classical approach was that it did not. A manager with theory y incli construct validation of a theory x y behavior scale. External motivation includes the forces which exist inside the individuals as well as the controlled by the manager, including items such as salaries, working conditions, company policy and job content items, such as recognition. Mcgregors theory xy and job performance digitalcommons. Theory x is management style where the emphasis is on productivity,on the. Pdf comparative analysis of theory x, theory y, theory z, and. Population and instrumentation the population consisted of 150 schools that had at least one principal. Theory into practice abraham maslow viewed mcgregor as a mentor.
Theory x and theory y also have implications in military command and control c2. Theory x and theory y to pick the best management style. When one studies x and y theory, one may form an impression that. Theory xy douglas mcgregor and theory z william ouichi. Mcgregor 2000 has pointed out that theory x management assumes that people generally are not responsible for work in contrast to theory y assuming that. The purpose of this paper is to apply mcgregors theory x and theory y to study teacher motivation in higher education. Nowadays mcgregors theory is seen as outdated, representing two extremes. Theory y implies that the managers should create and encourage a work environment which provides opportunities to employees to take initiative and selfdirection. Theory x and theory y was an idea devised by douglas mcgregor in his. Theory x assumes that people dislike work and will avoid doing anything they dont have to do. Mcgregor promoted theory y as the basis of good management practice, pioneering the argument that workers are not merely cogs in the company machinery, as theory x type organizations seemed to believe. Nov 25, 2019 theory x and theory y of motivation by mcgregors.
Humans expend the same amount of physical and mental effort in their work as in their private lives. He was a strong supporter of theories x and y, and he put theory y that people want to work, achieve and take responsibility into practice in a californian electronics factory. Correlational tests revealed that theory x assumptions were positively related to the dominant and impression leaving styles. The goal of managers using theory x management styles was to accomplish organizational goals through the organizations human. Theory x and theory y are still referred to commonly in the field of management and motivation, and whilst more recent studies have questioned the rigidity of the model, mcgregors x y theory remains a valid basic principle from. The dependent variable was satisfaction of the management style. An exploratory study of the relationships between theory x. Theory x style of management fosters a very hostile and distrustful atmosphere an authoritarian organization requires many managers just because they need to constantly control every single employee, and the method of control usually involves a fair amount of threat and coercion. Theory y people are selfmotivated and enjoy the challenge of work.
The relationship between theory xy management styles. Aug 24, 2010 critics of theory x generally focus their ire on the controllers. May 05, 2018 i it tends to overgeneralise and over simplify people as being one way or the other. Douglas mcgregor, through his wellknown theory x and theory y, drew a distinction between the assumptions about human motivation which underlie these two approaches, to this effect. Theory y, is an advanced theory, wherein it is assumed that the workers are selfdirected and selfmotivated, for growth and development and takes active part in decision making. Douglas mcgregors theory x vs theory y lucidchart blog. Criticism of theory x theory y nowadays mcgregors theory is seen as outdated, representing two extremes. Jun 30, 2016 organizational behaviour in the context of people management consists of several theories in which theory x, theory y, theory z are the newly introduced. Managers with this assumption motivate their people using a rigid carrot and stick approach, which rewards good performance and punishes poor performance. Theory x and theory y type leadership behavior and its impact. Theory y theory y managers role is to develop the potential in employees and help them to release that potential towards common goals. Mcgregors work was rooted in motivation theory alongside the works of abraham maslow, who created the hierarchy of needs. Theory x says that the average human being is lazy and selfcentred, lacks ambition, dislikes change, and longs to be told what to do. Copyright 2017, scholarly research journal for interdisciplinary.
Both of these theories begin with the premise that managements role is to assemble the factors of production, including people. I also would like to compare and contrast the two theories and detail how theory y fits better into the public administration field. I would like to compare douglas mcgregors theory x and y sets of human behavior assumptions with detailed information relating to mcgregors research and the philosophy behind each set x and y. It is believed that employees enjoy their work as natural as play and rest. For this study, however, the information about theory x male principals was used only in a comparison situation with theory y female principals. Theory x and theory y type leadership behavior and its. In his 1960 management book, the human side of enterprise, douglas mcgregor made his mark on the history of organizational management and motivational psychology when he proposed the two theories by which managers perceive employee motivation.
1273 1399 1281 997 924 341 52 1370 1513 152 796 485 1148 1502 1270 139 1552 119 142 643 893 795 1149 343 1648 554 509 104 130 620 1198 1032 236 817